GM Volt Forum banner

Nightmare in Returning Lease to US Bank or Scam?

35K views 66 replies 24 participants last post by  ampera_jed  
#1 · (Edited by Moderator)
A little over three years ago, I leased a 2014 Volt from Rydell using US Bank. Last December, my lease was nearing its term, so I scheduled an inspection with AutoVIN (as instructed by US Bank) and they assess about $260.00 in excess wear and tear. About a week before my term was up, I returned the car to a local Chevy dealer at about 1000 miles under and they gave me an odometer report.

A few weeks later, I got a bill from US Bank for the $260.00 plus $20.80 in sales tax. I happily wrote them a check for the full amount and thought everything was over.

Today, US Bank called me and said that they saw damage to the Volt in that the battery cables under the car was "sheared off" and that it would cost $10,000 to repair. They told me I could file a claim with my insurance company or I would have to pay off that bill.

This came as a shock to me and I have no idea how the battery cable could have possibly been "sheared off" by me. Is the Volt even driveable if the battery cables under the car is "sheared off"?

I am currently speaking to my insurance company and waiting for the report from US Bank. What a nightmare.
 
#10 ·
Debt collectors and repo men are also low lifes. Never lease and never buy until you have the cash. It's about the same amount of money, just learning to delay getting that new car until you've saved up the money rather than spending now and paying for it later with compouding interest working against you.
 
#6 ·
Hmm.. You might be right. I called US Bank using the number printed on my statement and the representative told me that I have a zero balance on my account and that was the end of the story.

As a precaution, I just added a security freeze on my SSN to all three credit agencies.
 
#9 ·
No, because this might turn into giant rate increases. Put the burden on caller to show you the car, show the damage, and prove that the damage wasn't caused by some dealership employee joyriding over rough terrain. When the car was turned in, the at was inspected, that should be that. Get an attorney that is so mean even you don't like him (or her) and rattle your saber that you've always wanted to own a piece of a finance company.
 
#7 ·
Scammers are relentless of coming up with new ways to steal, always get it in writing. No legitimate company would call on the phone ( or government like the IRS ), they would ALWAYS us US mail to inform you of an issue.

You should change the title of your thread to reflect a scam, its not US bank you have an issue with
 
#8 ·
I'm still not 100% sure this is a scam. I called US Bank back using the number printed on their statement and got transferred to the same department. I spoke to a US Bank rep and he said that my balance is showing zero, but the other department might know something he doesn't know. Unfortunately, their offices are now closed, so I can't get any additional information out of them today.

Here's a more technical question. If the battery cables on the bottom of the Volt were severed, would the car even be driveable?
 
#14 ·
I got two calls. 800-562-5205 and 800-437-1998. Searching the first number was inconclusive. The 2nd number seems to indicate a scammer. I'll call the official US Bank number printed on the US Bank statement tomorrow to confirm.
 
#16 ·
#18 ·
I think you're being scammed. You couldn't drive the car with any severed battery cables. The only one under the car is the APU cable and if it somehow got damaged there'd be warning lights aplenty, if the car didn't just shut down. It's an armored cable running along the fuel lines. Pretty hard to damage.
 
#19 ·
Interesting. If it's a scam, how do they get you to pay them without tipping their hand that they're not really US Bank? I mean if your insurance company gets involved, surely they'll figure out, or already know that this is a scam that's been done before.
 
#20 ·
They probably come up with something like this;
"Sir, you sound like a reasonable guy who's not trying to get away with this...so here's what we can do for you. In order to save extra handling charges and interest costs, if you can arrange to wire, or e-transfer $8000 to us by 10pm tonight when we close, that will square things away on our end...sound good"

Or something to that effect. Like somebody above said earlier, scammers are relentless in their efforts to come up with ways to help people part with their money. Because they know one thing for certain....and that is that a hard working honest person will do almost/pay almost ANYTHING, to make a problem go away. Never forget that
 
#21 ·
Sounds like a scam to me. Not only is the process odd, the claimed damage seems strange, the amount owed seems crazy high, and the amount is oddly even (ever get a car service bill for $100 even?). Plus, and perhaps to the point, US Bank has no record of the issue.

No doubt the idea is to let you negotiate what you owe "down" to a more reasonable amount.
 
#23 ·
I use my smartphone as my only phone. I screen my calls and do not answer any whose number is not identified either from my phone's address book or recognized by me. My thought is that any legitimate caller with an important topic will leave a voicemail. No voicemail, no call-back, and I call back only if I feel the message is important to me. It's amazing how many Caribbean cruises or Florida land ownership opportunities I miss out on:p:D

I was very, very leery upon turn-in to leave my 2012 leased Volt with the dealer to await an unscheduled arrival of an inspector. I took pictures of the car at the suggestion of the salesman who leased the car to me and who thoughtfully took off the plates for me, as well as the registration and inspection stickers on the windshield. I feel blessed that all went well for me and I got the letter of acceptance from US Bank a week or two later. I will never, never do a lease again! The risk is too great for my taste. Three months later I went back and bought the year-old 2014 from them (same salesman - actually, the only one trained in the Volt) that had been sitting on their lot and displayed in their showroom. It's been a very good car for me and great as a road car.

The OP's experience smells too much like a scam to me (my ex-wife hints at my being too cynical about people's motives). My advice to the OP is to call back on Monday and be very curt with whomever he speaks to telling them to send him a letter, including photos of the alleged damage, that he will have no further contact with them pending receipt of their letter and photos, and that he will no longer accept calls from them until the letter arrives. Politeness in this instance is unnecessary. IMHO, if this is legitimate, they will comply .

I'm sorry for the nightmare the OP is going through. This is a sh***y mess!
 
#24 ·
Leased 7 cars so far between us and never been a big issue. Take pictures and repair properly any damage that would be excessive and you should be fine. Tons of cars are leased and it is a good thing. Need people to buy and lease new cars or the whole industry fails. You can find just as many stories of people "stuck" with a car they don't like because they are upside down, car broke outside of warranty, etc..

Basically, this sounds like a scam and I don't think US Bank is any worse than others when it comes to lease returns.
 
#25 ·
UPDATE:

I called US Bank this morning (using the printed phone number on the statement) and another rep told me that I am showing a zero balance. I told the rep that someone from US Bank called me last week saying they found additional damage to the vehicle during auction, but the rep said the notes said they already billed me for it and it is showing a zero balance. The manager in charge wasn't in the office, so they'll have to call me back again.
 
#27 ·
US Bank finally called me back and it looks like this wasn't a scam caller. They emailed me the pictures of the damage, the estimate, and the transport receipt information. I don't know how much I can/should share because I believe this is now going through a formal arbitration procedure.
 
#31 ·
I changed our my tires before returning the vehicle and I recognize the tread pattern in the pictures I received. They also emailed me using the US Bank email and I also checked LinkedIn for the person's profile. While it's conceivable this is a very elaborate scam, I don't think it's likely. Regardless, they will be dealing with my insurance and I'm sure my insurance company is going to scrutinize everything.
 
#32 ·
That's my thought as well. The US Bank rep told me they ruled out transport damage because the bolts that were shorn had rust on them and that if the transport company had done the damage, the bolts would have been shiny at the shorn areas.

I don't completely buy this explanation because I returned the car on in early December and the vehicle was not transported until early January. So that's over a month that the car was out of my possession.

I'm no expert on rust formation, but I read that depending on weather conditions, it can form in a couple of days. I believe the transport from the dealership to the auction house did take several days.
 
#39 ·
'Tis a wicked world we live in...

Do you happen to know if the grounding straps are actually bolted to the battery? From the pictures, it seems that they are bolted to some sheet metal, but not necessarily the actual battery.