Today, regular fuel is $2.55 outside Anchorage - I am charged 0.18/kwh from utility co.
I commute 21.2 miles regularly - and when "zipping' around on errands, I return home with between 15-10 miles on battery. I don't fully charge overnight since I don't deplete the battery each day. But I am figuring these numbers based on full charging on the average 16kwh.
Full charge costs ~$2.88 for ~50miles or 0.0576 cents per mile (if I'm doing the mathematics correctly).
Prior, I owned a Mazda 3GT (short lived but 29mpgs) & a Jeep Renegade and averaged 19mpg.
For 50miles range Volt = $2.88 on the same range on Jeep = $6.71.
However, yesterday at 621miles, when pressing down and releasing the brake from a stop, the noise began re: For a "squeaking" type noise at the brake pedal during apply/release there is an updated braking "push-rod retainer" that alleviates the squeaking. The dealer should refer to Bulletin #16-NA-147 -- not sure if this is the exact culprit, but it happened regularly in stop and go in line at a drive through last night. I will pay particular attention to this today when I have it out and about.
Good luck, I can only say, I wished I had bought this car much earlier in life and encourage you and others to do it too. No car is 100% in all aspects - but this is really a fantastic driver - get the optional Confidence Package 1 though as a minimal : )