Joined

·
1,429 Posts

1 - 20 of 38 Posts

Joined

·
1,429 Posts

Joined

·
1,489 Posts

Joined

·
902 Posts

http://papers.sae.org/2015-01-1152/

You can preview the first 5 pages, which will show the charger efficiency for Gen 2 as 94.5% on Level 1 and 95.5% on Level 2. However, this does not account for battery efficiency, coolant pump losses, etc.

On the next page of this paper, the Charging System efficiency is given as 86.7% on Level 1 and 88.4% on Level 2 (vs. 79.3% and 81.4% respectively for Gen 1).

I believe these results can be different for various ambient conditions.

My electric rates are about 14.5 cents per kWh (thanks to a competitive energy supplier). Lately I haven't used any heat or AC in my 2016 Volt, and my calculated MPGe is about 145 mpg. With these numbers, I am just under 3 cents per mile.

Even at 50 mpg for gasoline, this is less than $1.50 per gallon equivalent. So I have no issues with the efficiency of the 2016 Volt.

Joined

·
1,539 Posts

I don't think it would be unreasonable to therefore assume 95% efficient delivery into the battery, and then 95% charging losses round trip in the battery.

Joined

·
1,429 Posts

There are two pieces of the electric bill, a generation charge and a distribution charge. I'm paying 11cents/KW as my generation charge from a competitive supplier but the total bill works out to about 21cents/KW which is typical for Massachusetts. Where do you live that you are paying only 14.5 cents?

http://papers.sae.org/2015-01-1152/

You can preview the first 5 pages, which will show the charger efficiency for Gen 2 as 94.5% on Level 1 and 95.5% on Level 2. However, this does not account for battery efficiency, coolant pump losses, etc.

On the next page of this paper, the Charging System efficiency is given as 86.7% on Level 1 and 88.4% on Level 2 (vs. 79.3% and 81.4% respectively for Gen 1).

I believe these results can be different for various ambient conditions.

My electric rates are about 14.5 cents per kWh (thanks to a competitive energy supplier). Lately I haven't used any heat or AC in my 2016 Volt, and my calculated MPGe is about 145 mpg. With these numbers, I am just under 3 cents per mile.

Even at 50 mpg for gasoline, this is less than $1.50 per gallon equivalent. So I have no issues with the efficiency of the 2016 Volt.

I second the ~90% figure while using 240V, based on my measurements.

I don't think it would be unreasonable to therefore assume 95% efficient delivery into the battery, and then 95% charging losses round trip in the battery.

However, this is only if not using any temperature conditioning (heating in winter, cooling in summer). I suspect the study numbers above took that into account.

Joined

·
1,539 Posts

Agreed. This is without battery heating or cooling. Whether it would be 'fair' to include that I wouldn't say, because it's not really a measure of charging efficiency but becomes one of 'operating' efficiency.I second the ~90% figure while using 240V, based on my measurements.

However, this is only if not using any temperature conditioning (heating in winter, cooling in summer). I suspect the study numbers above took that into account.

It doesn't seem reasonable to me, that the distribution charge be included in your vehicle propulsion costs, as you would still accrue that cost even if you didn't have the Volt.There are two pieces of the electric bill, a generation charge and a distribution charge. I'm paying 11cents/KW as my generation charge from a competitive supplier but the total bill works out to about 21cents/KW which is typical for Massachusetts. Where do you live that you are paying only 14.5 cents?

I'm in NH and have Eversource for my utility (formerly PSNH in NH, but owned by the former Northeast Utilities). My delivery (transmission and distribution) charges are about 8 cents. I recently went with Direct Energy for the energy supply, and they provide energy for 6.57 cents until November (6 month term).There are two pieces of the electric bill, a generation charge and a distribution charge. I'm paying 11cents/KW as my generation charge from a competitive supplier but the total bill works out to about 21cents/KW which is typical for Massachusetts. Where do you live that you are paying only 14.5 cents?

Let me know if you want to (or allowed to in MA) change to Direct Energy. They also offer a $50 gift card to me for providing the reference and for you as the referred party!

If the distribution charge is a rate per kWh, then of course it needs to be factored in as part of the energy costs for your Volt.It doesn't seem reasonable to me, that the distribution charge be included in your vehicle propulsion costs, as you would still accrue that cost even if you didn't have the Volt.

You may be thinking of the "customer charge", which is a flat fee per month. I exclude that from my propulsion costs, since I would pay exactly the same amount per month with or without charging my car.

--Chris

Joined

·
5,431 Posts

BTW, the best gasoline efficiency is less than 37% as most is lost as pure heat and sound (exhaust). So don't worry about charger efficiency as it is still better than any gas engine conversion. This is the main reason charging your Volt battery is much better than running the range extender.

Joined

·
1,489 Posts

If you're in the process of trying to decide whether to buy an EV or not then the savings you can realize by paying less for electricity than for gas are a part of the decision process. And you need to know the charging efficiency to get the most accurate estimate of your electricity costs because you're billed based on how much juice goes out of the wall socket, not how much goes into the battery.I don't have a Volt but why worry about the charge efficiency?

Even if you already own an electric car you may want to know how much you're paying to power it and the same rationale applies.

Joined

·
1,181 Posts

Breakevens need 4 pieces of data. You have two, the price per gallon and the price per kWh. You also need your driving efficiency under gas and electric. When I punch in your prices into my efficiency levels, I don't get breakeven. If you use typical efficiencies of say, 4miles/kWh and 40mpg, you'd get 5.25 cents/mile for electric and 7.5 cents/mile for gas.

Joined

·
1,539 Posts

(You mean per kWh, presumably?)The distribution charge is per KW it's not a flat rate so it has to be included in the cost per KW.

Just as a matter of interest... is the logic behind a per kWh distribution charge because drawing more electrons wears the wires out quicker?

Joined

·
1,429 Posts

Dist Chg First 600 KWH 0.04172376

Dist Chg Next 993 KWH 0.04834376

Transition Charge -0.00035

Transmission Charge 0.02829

Energy Efficiency Charge 0.01734343

Renewable Energy Charge 0.0005

Then the part which comes from a different supplier

Electricity Supply 0.1199

My total bill is $340.98 for 1593 KWH which comes out to 21.04 cents/KWH

If I understand your bill, the actual cost of the electricity is $0.1199/kWh, and the rest is overhead/infrastructure. The utilities are like the airlines, adding all types of charges to confuse the consumer and increasing their revenue. Our PGE gas/electric bill and telecom bills have so many additional charges, it is not clear what they all mean - another form of "nickeling and diming" us to add to their revenue.

Dist Chg First 600 KWH 0.04172376

Dist Chg Next 993 KWH 0.04834376

Transition Charge -0.00035

Transmission Charge 0.02829

Energy Efficiency Charge 0.01734343

Renewable Energy Charge 0.0005

Then the part which comes from a different supplier

Electricity Supply 0.1199

My total bill is $340.98 for 1593 KWH which comes out to 21.04 cents/KWH

Joined

·
1,429 Posts

The bottom line is that the competitive part of the bill, the supply charge, accounts for about half of the total charge but what really counts is the total charge which in my case (in Massachusetts) is 21.4 cents/KWH. Adjusting for a 90% charging efficiency that works out to 23.8 per KVA. The Volt has an 18.4KVA battery which will take you 53 miles at a cost of $4.38 (8.26 cents per mile). The gas engine in the Volt is 42MPG so the equivalent price per gallon is $3.46, the current price of gasoline in Massachusetts is about $2.31 for regular or $2.51 for mid grade.If I understand your bill, the actual cost of the electricity is $0.1199/kWh, and the rest is overhead/infrastructure. The utilities are like the airlines, adding all types of charges to confuse the consumer and increasing their revenue. Our PGE gas/electric bill and telecom bills have so many additional charges, it is not clear what they all mean - another form of "nickeling and diming" us to add to their revenue.

1 - 20 of 38 Posts

Join the discussion

GM Volt Forum

A forum community dedicated to Chevy Volt electric car owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about hybrid performance, modifications, classifieds, troubleshooting, maintenance, reviews, and more!

Full Forum Listing
Popular Communities

Join now to ask and comment!