I guess if you don't need the extra cargo space go with the ELR, but be warned, it requires premium gas and a much shorter overall range than the gen2 Volt. ELR=37mi electric 300mi overall vs. gen2 Volt=53mi electric and 420mi overall (on reg gas to boot!). Plus you'll pay more for tires in the ELR 20" vs. 17" in the Volt. You'll save more money overall with the gen2 Volt, but I guess if you've got the money and sportiness is the most important factor, then the ELR is a clear winner.